34,787 Pages

Crown Knight 10

The Quality Check Group, also known as the Crown Knights is a panel of Brickipedians who review, monitor, and improve all aspects of article ratings. The group consists of all members from the former Board of Reviewers and the Completeness Check Group, and inherit most of the abilities of both of those groups.

The following are duties of the Quality Check Group:

  1. Review all Featured Article nominations and either A) approve or B) reject them in a vote, based on the quality and adherence to FA criteria of the article. All FA noms have to be approved by a quorum of at least 3 panel members, with no objections from another panel member. Members of the Quality Check Group should include {{RG}} (which results in Crown Knights) before their sigs to make vote counting easier. FA candidates can be rejected without a panel vote if removal of the nomination is requested by the original nominator.
  2. Strike unnecessary or irrelevant objections from the FA nomination page. Members of the BoR have the power to strike objections on the Featured Article candidates page provided the objection has been addressed and the original objector has been absent for at least a week after an "objection addressed" comment is left on the FA candidates page, but only with a quorum of at least three panel members approving the removal of the objection, and less than two opposed. Additionally, FA objections can be struck by the Quality Check Group (as well as by any admin) if they do not fall under one of the rules.
  3. Review and possibly remove FA status from an article. QCG members also have the ability to strip an article of FA status, but only with approval of at least three members.
  4. Review nominations for article ratings, and either A) approve or B) reject them.



Voting for these forums are only for members of the check group but other users are free to join existing discussions.
View recent changes for these forums

Past FA review

Please look here for articles and contribute, vote, etc.

TopicLast editLast author
Featured article review archiveNever

Articles with contested or unclear status

If you come across an article that was deemed a certain class but disagree with this decision, or you are not sure whether or not an article actually meets the criteria for a certain class, discuss this here. Please look here for articles and contribute, vote, etc.

TopicLast editLast author
Minotaur (Minifigures)20:56, August 22, 2013Jeyo
Emma (Friends)20:55, August 22, 2013Jeyo
Agent M23:27, August 9, 2013NBP3.0
Class 3/4/5 distinctions11:50, September 25, 2011LcawteBot

Closed Discussions

This is an archive of previous discussions relating to articles with a contested or unlear status.

TopicLast editLast author
Nurse22:37, February 8, 2013Jeyo
Alien Mosquito23:56, November 8, 2012Jeyo
6776 Ogel Control Center22:17, November 3, 2012Jeyo
Part 3626bpb49222:14, November 3, 2012Jeyo
Lennox04:35, November 1, 2012Agent Fuse
3308 Side Stand05:36, October 27, 2012Agent Charge
Ninja (Minifigures)23:32, October 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
FA/GA nominations23:27, October 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
10143 Death Star II23:20, October 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
Star Wars (1)23:18, October 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
Spaceman (Minifigures)23:14, October 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
Forestman (Minifigures)23:12, October 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
Cheerleader23:11, October 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
Deep Sea Diver23:03, October 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
Daredevil00:59, October 23, 2012Captain Jag
Snike13:03, October 7, 2012NightblazeSaber
7774 Crab Crusher19:29, September 30, 2012Agent Charge
Space Alien23:12, September 10, 2012NightblazeSaber
6555 Sea Hunter23:06, September 10, 2012NightblazeSaber
Lifeguard23:05, September 10, 2012NightblazeSaber
KC59 Red Futuron Key Chain23:04, September 10, 2012NightblazeSaber
McDonald's Customer23:43, September 7, 2012NightblazeSaber
10186 General Grievous01:55, September 3, 2012NightblazeSaber
Chewbacca22:51, August 30, 2012NightblazeSaber
Fisherman06:52, August 30, 2012NightblazeSaber
6293 Furno05:20, August 28, 2012NightblazeSaber
Gorilla Suit Guy00:30, August 22, 2012NightblazeSaber
Explorer00:29, August 22, 2012NightblazeSaber
The Secret Journal of Dr. Artimus Rhodes00:22, August 22, 2012NightblazeSaber
Space Villain02:35, July 17, 2012NightblazeSaber
2160 Crystal Scavenger02:34, July 17, 2012NightblazeSaber
Elf02:29, July 17, 2012NightblazeSaber
Removing complete status procedure06:51, July 16, 2012NightblazeSaber
5905 Hidden Treasure06:49, July 16, 2012NightblazeSaber
Original Skeleton06:40, July 16, 2012NightblazeSaber
Vincent Crabbe11:40, June 25, 2012Berrybrick
4795 Ogel Underwater Base and AT Sub04:19, June 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
Samukai04:08, June 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
1680 Crusader's Cart04:04, June 25, 2012NightblazeSaber
Mace Windu23:33, June 24, 2012NightblazeSaber
Part 973px56204:36, June 24, 2012NightblazeSaber
2853588 Golden Dice04:32, June 24, 2012NightblazeSaber
4560059 Admiral's Daughter Key Chain04:30, June 24, 2012NightblazeSaber
Commander Fox04:24, June 24, 2012NightblazeSaber
7789 Lotso's Dump Truck04:24, June 24, 2012NightblazeSaber
KC10 Blue Futuron Key Chain20:28, June 16, 2012UltrasonicNXT
Baseball Player20:27, June 16, 2012UltrasonicNXT
Viktor Krum20:27, June 16, 2012UltrasonicNXT
6875 Hovercraft20:27, June 16, 2012UltrasonicNXT
Race Car Driver22:30, May 17, 2012NightblazeSaber
Professor Karkaroff22:30, May 17, 2012NightblazeSaber
4904 Elephant07:01, May 17, 2012NightblazeSaber
6441 Deep Reef Refuge (2)06:52, May 17, 2012SKP4472
852987 Penguin Key Chain09:09, March 12, 2012NightblazeSaber
Part 3206323:11, March 8, 2012NightblazeSaber
1776 Bonus Value Bucket05:52, March 8, 2012Mykheh
2732 Push & Go Train Station08:21, March 4, 2012Mykheh
6925 Interplanetary Rover03:49, March 2, 2012Mykheh
8399 K-9 Bot23:30, March 1, 2012Mykheh
Magician23:28, February 26, 2012NightblazeSaber
Padmé Naberrie22:02, January 15, 2012NightblazeSaber
3759 35th Anniversary Tub22:06, January 11, 2012NightblazeSaber
Han Solo22:03, January 11, 2012NightblazeSaber
Jack Sparrow21:59, January 11, 2012NightblazeSaber
Zane21:57, January 11, 2012NightblazeSaber
4482 AT-TE21:55, January 11, 2012NightblazeSaber
Scout Trooper12:23, November 4, 2011NightblazeSaber
Sumo Wrestler10:27, October 30, 2011NightblazeSaber
Obi-Wan Kenobi00:14, October 5, 2011NightblazeSaber
Mon Mothma00:13, October 5, 2011NightblazeSaber
R2-R700:11, October 5, 2011NightblazeSaber
Gypsy Moth08:03, September 30, 2011UltrasonicNXT
History of LEGO11:50, September 25, 2011LcawteBot
Anakin Skywalker11:49, September 25, 2011LcawteBot
5201 20 TECHNIC Angle Bricks Assorted11:49, September 25, 2011LcawteBot
Sulfurix16:56, August 12, 2011Mykheh
1605 Snail03:17, August 10, 2011Mykheh
Clone Trooper05:34, August 9, 2011Mykheh
Jango Fett05:21, August 9, 2011Mykheh
3334 Intelli-Train Tunnel05:20, August 9, 2011Mykheh
852272 Skeletons Battle Pack01:37, August 5, 2011Mykheh
6844 Seismologic Vehicle01:32, August 5, 2011Mykheh
6895 Spy-Trak I00:39, August 4, 2011Mykheh
5845 Dolphin Show19:27, August 3, 2011Mykheh
1016 Letter Bricks for Wall Board19:26, August 3, 2011Mykheh
010 Pre-School Set19:25, August 3, 2011Mykheh
5844 Laura with Surfboard21:03, July 30, 2011Mykheh
4207901 Star Wars Mini Bonus Pack07:10, July 26, 2011Mykheh
4052 Director07:08, July 26, 2011Mykheh
1491 Dual Defender07:05, July 26, 2011Mykheh
3582 Ant21:42, July 20, 2011Mykheh
Kai21:40, July 20, 2011Mykheh
4695 Mini Knight Bus (2)23:46, June 19, 2011C886553
2733 Push & Go Express04:51, June 14, 2011C886553
8968 River Heist04:50, June 14, 2011NightblazeSaber
7143 Jedi Starfighter04:50, June 14, 2011C886553
7977 Seabed Strider04:41, June 14, 2011NightblazeSaber
Star Wars (2)00:51, June 11, 2011NightblazeSaber
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.